Blog / Top 5 Players Who Represented Both Man Utd and Liverpool

Football October 16th, 2025
Top 5 Players Who Represented Both Man Utd and Liverpool

Source: Alamy Stock Photo

Top 5 Players Who Represented Both Man Utd and Liverpool

Crossing the divide between Manchester United and Liverpool is extraordinarily uncommon, yet several prominent footballers have achieved this feat throughout history.

England's two most decorated football clubs are separated by merely 32 miles, sharing a fierce competitive relationship that has endured for more than 120 years between Manchester United and Liverpool.

Within this piece, we examine an exceptional category of footballer who has put pen to paper at both Old Trafford and Anfield throughout their playing days.

Paul Ince

After spending time with West Ham from age 14, Paul Ince sparked controversy with his September 1989 transfer to Manchester, costing £1million.

The central midfielder posed for photographs wearing a United kit prior to finalizing his Old Trafford switch, which provoked fury amongst most Hammers supporters.

However, Ince delivered immediate results on the field, claiming the FA Cup during his debut campaign (1989-90) before contributing significantly to United securing their inaugural league championship in 26 years (1992-93).

Across six years, the London-born player accumulated more than 200 matches for the Red Devils and secured six significant honours – including two Premier League championships, two FA Cups, one League Cup, and the European Cup Winners Cup.

Ince departed Old Trafford during summer 1995 for Italian powerhouse Inter Milan, where his energetic playing style rapidly won over supporters.

Following two campaigns at the San Siro, the 30-year-old's return to the Premier League with Liverpool was confirmed.

Given his United connections, certain Liverpool supporters remained doubtful, but Ince strengthened his rapport with fans by netting equalizing goals against both Everton and United.

The England international registered 65 matches for the Reds prior to his summer 1999 departure to Middlesbrough.

Michael Owen

Emerging from Liverpool's youth system, Michael Owen was recognized as an exceptional prospect from his earliest years.

The forward's senior debut came at merely 17 years old, entering as a substitute to find the net against Wimbledon in May 1997.

He became a regular starter the subsequent season and claimed the Premier League Golden Boot, alongside being honored as PFA Young Player of the Year.

Owen secured an FA Cup, two League Cups, and a UEFA Cup (currently known as the Europa League) during his Anfield tenure, while also receiving the Ballon d'Or in 2001.

The England striker subsequently completed a prominent transfer to Real Madrid in 2004, managing only 36 outings before departing for Newcastle in 2005.

In 2009, after the Magpies' descent from the premier division and despite battling fitness issues, Owen received an opportunity from Sir Alex Ferguson to join Man Utd.

The attacker accepted the offer and captured a Premier League and League Cup across his three-year spell at Old Trafford.

Peter Beardsley

Following impressive performances at Carlisle and Canadian side Vancouver Whitecaps, Peter Beardsley arrived at Old Trafford after being recruited by manager Ron Atkinson.

Notwithstanding his clear talent, circumstances didn't favor him at United, and he recorded merely one League Cup outing before transferring to Newcastle in September 1983.

Four years following his Old Trafford exit, Beardsley was acquired by major adversaries Liverpool, forming part of Kenny Dalglish's squad reconstruction.

The attacker proved an inspirational signing for the Reds and contributed to Dalglish's side capturing two Division One championships and an FA Cup throughout his four-year Anfield period.

In 1991, Beardsley generated further attention by joining another select group, entering the distinguished circle of players to represent both Everton and Liverpool.

Phil Chisnall

Manchester-born in 1942, Phil Chisnall progressed through Man Utd's academy after signing two months following the Munich air tragedy.

The striker accumulated merely 35 senior matches across five years, significantly hindered by a severe knee problem.

In 1964, Chisnall's transfer to Liverpool was confirmed, and he contributed to the Reds capturing the First Division championship that campaign.

He exited Merseyside in 1967 and subsequently represented Southend and Stockport, having performed under iconic managers Matt Busby and Bill Shankley.

Fred Hopkin

Yorkshire native Fred Hopkin launched his professional journey at Darlington before transferring to Man Utd in 1919, making his maiden appearance at Derby that August.

He netted 11 times across 74 matches for the Red Devils, including a goal in a 3-3 Manchester Derby stalemate with City in 1919.

The winger left Old Trafford in 1921 and completed a switch to Liverpool, managed by David Ashworth at the time.

Hopkin subsequently registered over 330 matches for the Reds and became a crucial member of the team that secured consecutive league championships in 1921-22 and 1922-23.

Visit Betway's Premier League betting page.